This page is about Richard Stallman’s “Incorrect Quotation” article. It in turn is about a quote commonly misattributed to Stallman, the founder of the GNU project, of which the main point is that calling a Linux system “Linux” is incorrect, but rather the term “GNU/Linux” (and then preferably pronounced “GNU plus Linux”) should be used. Because Linux is not a full operating system, and the systems called “Linux” are actually a version of the GNU system based on Linux.
Stallman corrects the content of the post like this:
The main error is that Linux is not strictly speaking part of the GNU system—whose kernel is GNU Hurd. The version with Linux, we call “GNU/Linux.” It is OK to call it “GNU” when you want to be really short, but it is better to call it “GNU/Linux” so as to give Torvalds some credit.
The GNU system runs the GNU Hurd kernel and versions with Linux are called GNU/Linux.
The much bigger problem with the quotation, in my opinion, is the following part, which Stallman states he actually did say himself:
Linux is normally used in combination with the GNU operating system: the whole system is basically GNU with Linux added, or GNU/Linux.
First of all: this is false. Plenty of Linux-based environments are not based on GNU. Take Alpine Linux, for example, with BusyBox replacing GNU coreutils and various higher-level userland utilities (GNU findutils, etc.), musl replacing glibc, and the rest of this supposed “GNU operating system”, which can be used optionally on Alpine and other “GNU/Linux” distros, being barely able to qualify as part of apparently such a basic OS, to which components have to be added: for example GNU make, GNU gzip and GCC Or look at Android, a Linux-based OS, but with a famously foreign userspace, both in relation to POSIX-ish ones, and by extension GNU.
But even if it were true in every single case – even if every single Linux system was Linux with GNU added, it would be pretty nonsensical to conclude that all of those systems should be called “GNU plus Linux”. Because “GNU with Linux added” is not a useful definition of the environment. Only a fraction of people saying their tool is made for “Linux” actually depend on “GNU with Linux added”. Often they either just depend on the kernel itself, or a “conventional Linux userspace”/POSIX-compliant environment/Unix-like environment, sometimes implemented by GNU, sometimes implemented by BusyBox, sometimes implemented by something else. And cases where they do in fact depend GNU, this is more often than not either a failure to depend on generic Linux or Unix-like interfaces: incidentally depending on GNU-specific POSIX extensions because that is the environment the developer and many users happen to use, or just some explicit dependency on some pieces of software originating from GNU. Take for example mkinitcpio, a tool that depends on various parts of the GNU operating system, notably Bash, but far from GNU in its entirety.
I think that this all makes “Linux” a perfectly usable term to describe Linux systems, or at least preferred over the overreaching “GNU/Linux”, unless the environment in question specifically guarantees GNU/Linux, as in GNU with Linux added, semantics.